How to choose a personal trainer in Zurich: 7 questions to ask before you pay

The short answer to how to choose a personal trainer: ask seven questions in the first conversation and listen to how they’re answered. What do they need to know about you first, can you see the program written down, how will they set your starting weight, how will progress be measured, what did they study, what happens if they’re sick, and do they sell supplements or promise a number. A trainer’s method shows in the answers, not on the website. Chemistry matters, but you test it last, in the trial session. I’ve sat on the other side of it for years; the good trainers don’t mind.

At CHF 130 to 195 per 60-minute session at a studio like ours, most people buy ten or twenty sessions at a time (how much does a personal trainer cost). That’s a few thousand francs riding on instinct, and instinct is good at judging whether you like someone and useless at judging whether they can program. Programming decides whether you’re stronger in twelve weeks, and it’s what I’d want you paying for.

How to choose a personal trainer: the seven questions

1. “What do you need to know about me before you write my program?”

A good answer lists things: injuries and current pain, training history in months and years (not “I used to be sporty”), how much you sleep, what your job does to your body, and how many sessions a week you’ll realistically do. Our 12-week block assumes three; at one a week it takes 36, and you should hear that before you buy. I say it in the first conversation, even when it costs me the sale. At VAULT the intake also includes a health screening and four questions almost nobody else asks: what would success look like to you, what would failure look like, how committed are you from 1 to 10, and if you slip, how do you want us to react. That last one decides whether you get a strict coach or a patient one.

A bad answer is a program that appears before any of that. If the trainer already knows what you’ll do on Monday, it isn’t your program. I’ve been shown these at intake; they’re all the same program.

2. “Can I see the program written down, with the progression rule?”

Good: a block of 8 to 12 weeks, the same exercises throughout, and a one-line rule for how the load goes up. Ours reads: work in 8 to 12 reps; when every set reaches 12, add 2.5 to 5 kg on upper-body lifts (5 to 10 kg on lower-body lifts) and drop back to 8. That’s double progression. A client understands it and a different coach can continue it. I like a rule a client can repeat back to me.

Bad: “we’ll see how you feel on the day”, or exercises that change every session. Variety feels like personalisation. It’s the opposite. I stopped programming a new exercise every session years ago because nobody, me included, could tell who’d got stronger. If the exercise changes every week, nobody can tell whether you got stronger, and progressive overload, the one thing that reliably builds muscle, never happens.

3. “How will you decide my starting weight?”

Good: by testing it, in the session, with you. We use a two-set method. Set one at a clearly conservative weight, 8 to 10 clean reps, then the question: “how many more could you have done?” If the answer is five or six, the weight goes up. Set two heavier, same question. When the answer is “one or two”, that’s your starting weight.

One caveat: beginners are bad at that question. Among 141 lifters, the least experienced underestimated the reps they had left by four to five, the most experienced by one to two (Steele et al., 2017). So in the first weeks a coach should treat your “two left” as four, and teach you the difference on a machine, not with a barbell on your back. In my first weeks with any beginner, “two left” means four until they’ve proved otherwise.

Bad: percentages of a one-rep max you’ve never tested, or “we’ll go to failure and see”. Training to failure isn’t superior to stopping short of it for muscle growth (Refalo et al., 2023), and on a free-weight squat in week one it’s how people get hurt. I’ve seen enough of those.

4. “How will we know it worked?”

Good: the same tests at the start and the end of the block. Ours are grip strength on a dynamometer, left and right; maximum air squats in 30 seconds; maximum push-ups; 15 calories on the rower and 15 on the bike; and hours of sleep, which is a test too (I ask because it changes what I’d program that day). Every set is logged, so the load on your main lifts in week 12 is a number, not a feeling.

Grip strength is there on purpose. In almost 140,000 adults across 17 countries, every 5 kg less grip strength went with a 16% higher risk of death from any cause, and grip predicted cardiovascular death better than systolic blood pressure did (Leong et al., 2015). Thirty seconds, and it tells me a lot about your starting point.

Bad: “you’ll feel it”, or a re-test that never gets scheduled. A test nobody repeats measures nothing.

5. “What did you study?”

“Qualified” can mean two very different things. One is a BSc or MSc in sport science: three to five years of physiology, biomechanics and enough statistics to know when a study is weak. The other is a certificate earned over a weekend. Nobody stops the second group from using the same job title, so ask. Our coaches hold a BSc or MSc in sport science (the team).

A second, more practical signal is Qualitop, the Swiss quality label for fitness providers. It certifies the personal-training method specifically, and a list of insurers contribute to training under it (Qualitop). VAULT is Qualitop-certified for personal training. Sessions may be partly reimbursed depending on your supplementary insurance (Zusatzversicherung); the amount varies by insurer and some policies don’t include it, so ask yours first.

Bad: a list of course names you can’t look up, or a change of subject. A trainer who’s proud of their education answers in one sentence. Mine: five years of sport science in Spain, then a master’s in high performance in sports.

6. “What happens if you’re sick, or if I want a different coach?”

Good: nothing happens to your program. It’s written down, every set and every load, so another coach picks it up on the same page. At VAULT you train with VAULT rather than with one person. Coaches rotate, and every session ends with a note for the next one (“dropped the Bulgarian split squat to 3×8, right knee complained at full depth, try step-ups if it persists”). Some people dislike the idea at first, and I understand it; they came for a person. Then their coach goes on holiday and they don’t lose two weeks.

Bad: “I know all my clients by heart.” A compliment to their memory, a risk to your progress.

7. “Do you sell supplements, or promise a number?”

If either answer is yes, I’d keep looking. A trainer who earns on your protein powder has a conflict of interest every time food comes up. A trainer who promises “minus eight kilos by December” is promising something they don’t control. What a coach can honestly promise is a clear, measured improvement on your starting point. Not the exact result you pictured, on the date you picked. I don’t make that promise.

Nutrition still matters, and a good coach will talk to you about protein, daily steps and sleep. Nutrition coaching at VAULT is done by Roberta Burla (MAS ETH in Nutrition and Health, IOC Sports Nutritionist), not by the training coaches. In Switzerland dietetics is a regulated profession with its own degree (SVDE), and neither I nor the training coaches use that title.

Five red flags from the floor

Any one of these would end it for me:

  1. No questions about injuries before the first loaded exercise.
  2. No training log. If nobody writes the weight down, nobody’s progressing it.
  3. Exercises that change every session.
  4. A promised number of kilos by a date.
  5. Free-weight squats or deadlifts to failure in week one. The first eight sessions are for learning to brace and to hip hinge.

Chemistry matters. It comes last.

Most guides lead with “compatibility”, and so did the old version of this article, which I should have fixed sooner. It isn’t wrong, it’s in the wrong place: the coach you like most may be the one with no progression rule, and you find out three months later. Ask the seven questions first. If two trainers pass, pick the one you’d rather spend sixty minutes a week with.

The trial session tests both, and if you’re still deciding between a personal training studio and a gym, this guide to fitness studios in Zurich comes first. The trial tests: whether the coach asks before they load, whether the plan is written, and whether you’d come back on Thursday. Ours happens at VAULT Training, Brandschenkestrasse 150, 8002 Zürich (Enge), with public parking next door.

Two things you’ll read elsewhere that we’d cross out

“Consider an online personal trainer.” A program you follow alone at home is a document, not personal training. Nobody sees your hip hinge. We don’t offer it, and I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone still learning to lift.

“Here are ten benefits of a personal trainer.” You don’t need a list to choose between two trainers, and I won’t give you one here. If you’re still deciding whether to have a coach at all, that case is made in why personal trainers are worth it.

Frequently asked questions

What qualifications should a personal trainer have?

A BSc or MSc in sport science, because it covers physiology, biomechanics and how to read a study; a weekend certificate doesn’t. Ask to see it. In Switzerland, Qualitop certification for the personal-training method is the practical second signal, because insurers check it before they contribute.

How do I know if my personal trainer is good?

Four things you can check in the first two sessions: they ask about injuries before loading you, the program is written down with a rule for increasing the weight, every set is logged, and a re-test date is on the calendar. Missing those four, the sessions are workouts, not progress.

Is personal training covered by health insurance in Switzerland?

Not by basic insurance. Some supplementary policies (Zusatzversicherung) contribute to training with a Qualitop-certified provider; how much depends on the insurer and the policy, and some policies contribute nothing. Ask your insurer before you buy a pack.

Bring these seven questions to a free trial session with us. If we can’t answer every one to your satisfaction, you’ve lost an hour and gained a checklist for the next studio. Book a free trial.